N.Y. Attorney General’s Office, SEC and FINRA Assess Penalties, Fines Against Securities Firm Over Dark Pool Access Disclosures
On December 16, N.Y. Attorney General Eric Schneiderman announced a $37 million settlement against a major securities firm following its joint investigation with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) into allegedly false statements and omissions made by the firm in connection with the marketing of its electronic order routing services, known as its “Dark Pool Ranking Model.” As explained by Attorney General Schneiderman, “Electronic order routing systems that route investor orders to various markets, including dark pools, are a part of modern equities trading, and companies that promote their routing capabilities must do so truthfully.” As part of the agreement, the firm admitted that it misled investors and violated New York State and federal securities laws; its conduct was also censured by both regulators.
That same day, FINRA announced its decision to fine the same firm $3.25 million for failing to disclose accurate information to all clients about services and features of its alternative trading system (ATS). In Form ATS filings with the SEC, the firm represented that all ATS users would have “identical access” to the system’s services and features. However, FINRA found that some ATS users, including high-frequency traders, were provided with more information than others and received services not available to others. The firm settled without admitting or denying the charges.